“What is a patent worth?” is one of the hardest questions in intellectual property. Most answers rely on gut feeling, success stories or correlations that prove nothing – maybe good companies simply file more patents? One US study found a clever way to answer the question cleanly, and its results should interest every founder.
The experiment nobody planned: the “patent lottery”
Three researchers – Joan Farre-Mensa, Deepak Hegde and Alexander Ljungqvist – noticed a simple fact: at the US Patent Office, applications reach examiners almost at random, and some examiners are more lenient than others. Two startups with similar inventions may get different outcomes purely because of the examiner they drew.
The researchers used this “lottery” and analyzed data on all first-time patent applications filed in the US since 2001. This let them compare similar startups whose only difference was whether they won their first patent. The study was published in 2020 in The Journal of Finance.
The findings, in numbers
Startups that “won the lottery” and received their first patent showed, on average, five years later:
- 55% higher employment growth
- 80% higher sales growth
- A 47% higher chance of raising venture capital in the three years after the patent
- 56.5% more subsequent patents and 33% more citations per patent – more, and better, follow-on innovation
Why does a patent make the difference?
According to the researchers, the main channel is access to capital. To an investor, a young startup is a black box: it is hard to tell whether the technology is truly new and valuable. A granted patent is an external, credible signal – a government examiner has checked that there is something new here. That signal opens doors to VCs, banks and public-market investors, and with the money come employees, sales and more inventions.
Four takeaways for founders
- The first patent matters most. The strongest effect was measured on a company’s first patent – when investors know the least about it.
- Application quality is not a lottery. You cannot choose your examiner, but you can reduce your dependence on luck: a thorough prior-art search, well-drafted claims and a complete description lower the risk of rejection even before a strict examiner.
- Speed is money. If the patent is a signal to investors, it should arrive before the funding round. The USPTO offers accelerated examination tracks worth considering when a raise is near.
- Plan for the US from day one. The study covers the US market, home to most VCs that invest in Israeli startups. A patent registration strategy that starts in Israel and continues to the US should be built around your fundraising timeline.
An important caveat
These are averages measured on US startups. A patent will not save a product with no market, and there is no guarantee every company will grow at the same rate. But the study offers a rare, data-driven answer to a question founders ask every day: a patent is not only legal protection – it is a growth engine.
Want a patent strategy that supports your next raise? Contact us.
Sources
- Farre-Mensa, Hegde & Ljungqvist – What Is a Patent Worth? Evidence from the U.S. Patent “Lottery” (NBER Working Paper 23268)
- The Journal of Finance, vol. 75(2), 2020, pp. 639–682
Adv. Uzi Havosha – Attorney specializing in patent drafting and startup commercialization